Jefferson and Slavery

Reading Level:


Who Lived at Monticello

Who Lived at Monticello

A graphical chart of the free and enslaved community at Monticello in the 1790s. Graphic design by Josef Beery
Click to enlarge

Thomas Jefferson spent his entire life in the company of African-American slaves. Jupiter, born in 1743 (the same year Jefferson was born) was his childhood companion. He later became Jefferson’s personal servant, traveling with his master all over Virginia. Slaves accompanied Jefferson to Philadelphia, where he wrote the Declaration of Independence. They sailed with him to France, where he was a diplomat.

Over his lifetime, Thomas Jefferson owned over six hundred slaves. When Jefferson was twenty-one, he inherited about thirty slaves from his father. Later, he inherited 135 more from John Wayles, his wife’s father. By 1796, Jefferson owned about 170 slaves.

At Monticello, Jefferson and his family were surrounded by African Americans. They were necessary for running the 5,000-acre plantation, which consisted of four separate farms. Enslaved workers plowed the fields, planted the wheat, drove the wagons, cared for the livestock and constructed the buildings. In the house they stoked the fires, prepared the food, washed the clothes and cared for the children. The lives of Jefferson and his family were entwined with the lives of his enslaved workers.

Edmund Bacon, Monticello’s overseer for sixteen years recalled that Jefferson “was always very kind and indulgent to his servants. He would hardly ever allow them to be overworked, and he would hardly ever allow one of them to be whipped.” But by law, Jefferson’s slaves were his property. And he treated them as property. When circumstances required it, he bought and sold them, gave them as wedding gifts, and hired or leased them out. Slaves who refused to obey were punished and some were sold “South.” And Jefferson granted only seven slaves their freedom.

 

Jefferson’s Views on Slavery

Jefferson lived during a time when slavery was a well-established and accepted system in many countries. By the time he was twenty-one, slaves had been in the colonies for about 145 years. Jefferson owned slaves throughout his lifetime. But he also felt that slavery had been forced upon his generation. He was against the slave trade, but felt that his ability to make changes was limited.

In 1774, he expressed his frustration with Great Britain’s King George III in A Summary View of the Rights of British America. “The abolition of domestic slavery is the great object of desire in those colonies, where it was unhappily introduced in their infant state.” He went on to state that the colonies’ attempts to stop the African slave trade had been “defeated by his Majesty’s negative.”

Declaration of Independence

Original copy of the Declaration of Independence

Original copy of the Declaration of Independence at the National Archives in Washington, DC. Image Courtesy the National Archives and Records Administration
Click to enlarge

In 1776, Jefferson’s strong attack on the slave trade in the draft of the Declaration of Independence was deleted by the Continental Congress. In 1808, when Jefferson was president, he helped to steer through a law that ended America’s participation in the international slave trade. However, the buying and selling of slaves continued within the states.

Jefferson always believed that slavery was an unjust system. He called it an “abominable crime.” He favored a plan of gradual emancipation (freedom) that called for the freed slaves to be expatriated (removed outside the United States). He felt that slavery had created such fear and anger between whites and blacks that they could not live together in a stable society. Jefferson wrote that the races would have to be separated because of “deep rooted prejudices entertained by the whites; ten thousand recollections, by the blacks, of the injuries they have sustained.” Slaves made up over half the total population of Virginia. Jefferson felt that freeing them would not be a simple task and became more and more silent on the issue.

Why then did the man who wrote “all men are created equal” and who believed slavery was a crime continue to own slaves? Historians have debated many reasons.

 

The Law

Slavery was the law of the land. At the time, Jefferson was not willing to go against the laws by freeing a large number of people from slavery. In the late 1770s, he wrote up a plan of gradual emancipation for the slaves in Virginia. He did not present it to the legislature because he felt the “public mind” was not ready for the idea. Jefferson continued to hope that the state would call another constitutional convention, at which his plan could be debated. This did not occur until after his death.

 

Wheat and Rye

In the 1790s, Jefferson began growing wheat and other grains at Monticello instead of tobacco.


Click to enlarge

Labor

The plantation economy and southern way of life that Jefferson was born into depended upon slavery. Over half of the signers of the Declaration of Independence owned slaves. Like Jefferson, they needed enslaved laborers for their plantations. Jefferson owned over 10,000 acres at his Monticello and Poplar Forest plantations. He needed large numbers of workers to raise his livestock and his cash crops (tobacco and, later, wheat) and to support the plantation through work as carpenters, blacksmiths, textile workers, and wagoners.

 

Finances

For much of his life Thomas Jefferson was in debt. When he died in 1826 he owed more than $100,000 (about four million dollars in today’s money). Other than his land, Jefferson’s largest investment was in his slaves. When he died, Monticello’s slaves were sold instead of freed. Their sale made money, freeing Jefferson’s family from some of his debt.

Race

Like many people during the time, Jefferson believed general misconceptions (untruths) about African Americans. In his book Notes on the State of Virginia (published 1781-1782), he wrote about the physical and intellectual differences between whites, blacks and Native Americans. About Africans he said that “inferiority is not the effect merely of their condition in life.” It is a “suspicion only, that the blacks . . . are inferior to the whites in the endowments of both body and mind.” Although Jefferson believed that God had given slaves the same rights as other men, he was not sure they were capable of using these rights. These misconceptions persisted despite his daily encounters with the intelligent and skilled enslaved men and women who surrounded him at Monticello.

 

Sale of Monticello Ad

Sale of Monticello Ad

Jefferson's grandson ran this ad announcing the public sale of Monticello and other personal property including "130 valuable negroes."
Click to enlarge

The Question Still Remains

In his will, George Washington granted freedom to his slaves and their children. By 1804, all the northern states had set dates for ending slavery within their own borders. Thomas Jefferson, however, freed only seven slaves. He freed two in his lifetime and five in his will. Why didn’t he grant freedom to the rest, at least after his death?

When Jefferson died in 1826, he was $107,000 in debt. Six months later, crowds flocked to Monticello for an auction. There they bid on Jefferson’s property, which would be sold to help pay his debt. This included “household furniture”, crops, livestock, and “130 valuable negroes.”

Slaves such as Joseph Fossett, who was soon to be free, watched his wife and children sold to different bidders. Joseph’s son Peter Fossett was eleven years old at the time of the sale. Later, Peter recalled that he was “born and reared as free, not knowing I was a slave, then suddenly . . . put upon an auction block and sold to strangers.” Sadly, Thomas Jefferson, the man who wrote “all men are created equal” was not able to grant equality to the enslaved men and woman who called Monticello home.